Why is alcoholism different than a smoking addiction?

Why is it harder for an alcoholic to stop drinking alcohol than it is for a smoker to stop smoking cigarettes? I know alcoholism is a disease while smoking is an addiction…

Thanks!
I’m not asking if it’s a disease or not. I know for a fact it’s a disease and there is near-countless scientific data to prove so.

Now, any real answers from someone who actually knows what they’re talking about?


9 Responses

  1. css0199 says:

    they’re the same. they are both addictions, just not both socially acceptable.

  2. J R says:

    an addiction is an addiction they both mentally and physically hurt you and your loved ones

  3. Frankie V says:

    Alcoholism isn’t a disease. That’s bullcrap. It’s an addiction. I don’t care what any doctor says he proves. An addiction is an addiction.

  4. MiMi says:

    Nicotine which is what the addictive ingredient in cigarettes is a stimulant just like caffeine. But, alcohol is a downer.

  5. ~DaNi~ says:

    well i’m only 14. no expert.

    but a disease is something u develop or catch. it’s physical. ur body adjusts 2 alcohol. it craves alcohol.

    same thing wid marijuana, cigarettes, booze

    but an addiction is more mental. ur brain wants it.

    altho. honestly alcoholism is only a disease when it gives u long term effects. til then it’s just an addiction

  6. mariko m says:

    Alcohol addiction can harm your health. Many people have lost jobs, homes, and loved ones simply because they could not tame thier alcohol habit. I suggest you find some help. Here is a site that has addiction information and a directory of addiction treatment clinics so you can help. http://www.addictionselfhelp.com

    Live strong

  7. JR says:

    I don’t know that it is. I smoked and drank alcoholically for approximately 13 years. I have seven and a half years of sobriety and six and a half without smoking.

    I quit both because of adverse health effects and my wife’s unhappiness with my behavior. I took advantage of an out patient treatment program and AA to get sober and stay sober.

    I stopped smoking because I was sick and tired of coughing, chest infections and general poor health. One day I made up my mind to not by any more cigarettes. I’m not sure I ever officially quit smoking. It was easier for me just to not buy anymore. Before this I tried Welbutran, the patch and other smoking cessation programs. None worked for very long.

    I clearly made poor chooses and allowed myself to rationalize both behaviors with flawed logic.

    So, in my experience, smoking and drinking alcoholically are very difficult to overcome and I wouldn’t say that one was more or less difficult than the other.

  8. Ted F says:

    I don’t think you can be that general when it comes to breaking strong addictions like cigarettes and alcohol; it all depends on the victim. Some people find it harder to quit smoking than alcohol, and vice verse. I think that a big factor in this is how much that person is exposed to the alcohol and/or tobacco. The more someone is exposed to it, the more tempting it will seem. So I think the best way to break a habit like that is to go somewhere like rehab, where you can’t be tempted by the drugs/alcohol.

  9. balloonluvr says:

    Because smoking stinks, kills everbody and everything around too. Disgusting to say the least.

© Effective Drug Rehabilitation
CyberChimps